Why Employees Don’t Use Mental Health Benefits and What Actually Works

Executive Summary

Employers are investing heavily in workplace mental health benefits. From Employee Assistance Programs to teletherapy platforms and wellness apps, organizations are expanding access to behavioral health support at an unprecedented pace. Yet one challenge continues to undermine these investments: employees are not consistently using the resources available to them.

Low utilization does not mean low need. Rates of anxiety, depression, burnout, and substance use challenges remain high across industries. The gap between availability and engagement reveals a deeper issue in how workplace mental health support is designed and delivered.

This whitepaper explores why employees do not use traditional mental health benefits and outlines what actually drives engagement. It examines the role of confidentiality, stigma reduction, certified peer support, continuous digital engagement, and family access in creating meaningful outcomes. Most importantly, it reframes the conversation from access to accountability and measurable impact.

For employers seeking stronger returns on their behavioral health investments, engagement is the leading indicator of success.

‍

The Rapid Growth of Workplace Mental Health Benefits

Over the past decade, workplace mental health benefits have expanded dramatically. Employers now offer:

• Employee Assistance Programs
• Teletherapy and virtual counseling
• Mental health apps
• Wellbeing stipends
• Substance use support services

This expansion reflects growing awareness that mental health directly affects productivity, retention, safety, and workplace culture. According to multiple workforce studies, untreated mental health conditions contribute to absenteeism, presenteeism, disability claims, and turnover.

At the same time, substance use challenges continue to impact working adults across industries. Many employees struggling with alcohol or other substances remain undetected until performance declines or safety risks increase.

Despite expanded access, traditional EAP utilization rates often remain in the single digits. Many digital tools see initial downloads but limited sustained engagement. Employers are left asking a critical question: if the benefits are available, why are employees not using them?

The Engagement Problem in Workplace Mental Health

Low Utilization Does Not Mean Low Need

Employees frequently struggle in silence. Fear of professional consequences prevents many from seeking help. Concerns about confidentiality, stigma, or being perceived as weak discourage engagement.

In competitive workplace environments, employees may worry that accessing mental health or substance use support could impact promotions, performance reviews, or job security. Even when employers emphasize privacy, uncertainty often remains.

Stigma Remains a Powerful Barrier

Although conversations about mental health have become more common, stigma persists. Substance use challenges carry an even greater level of silence and shame. Employees may avoid support simply to protect their identity within the workplace.

Stigma reduces early intervention. Instead of seeking help when symptoms first appear, many wait until they reach a crisis point. By then, performance, morale, and team dynamics may already be affected.

Reactive Models Do Not Drive Behavior Change

Traditional mental health benefits are often reactive. Employees must recognize a need, search for resources, schedule appointments, and commit to ongoing sessions. This requires time, energy, and emotional readiness.

Behavioral change, however, requires consistency. One appointment or a short term intervention rarely produces lasting results without ongoing accountability and daily reinforcement.

When benefits are episodic rather than continuous, engagement fades quickly.

The Family Factor Is Often Ignored

Mental health and substance use challenges do not exist in isolation. They affect entire households. Stress at home directly influences workplace focus, productivity, and emotional regulation.

Most workplace mental health solutions focus solely on the employee. When family members lack support, stressors remain unresolved. Employees carry that burden into their workday, reducing the effectiveness of employer sponsored programs.

What Actually Drives Employee Engagement in Mental Health Benefits

To improve employee engagement in mental health benefits, employers must shift from passive access to proactive, personalized support. Research and real world outcomes consistently show that the following elements increase sustained participation.

Confidential and Anonymous Access

Confidentiality is foundational. When employees feel safe, they are more likely to engage early and consistently.

Digital platforms that allow anonymous participation reduce fear and lower the threshold for first use. Employees can explore support without concern about workplace visibility.

Removing perceived risk encourages proactive behavior rather than crisis driven action.

Continuous Digital Engagement

Effective digital mental health solutions provide ongoing touchpoints rather than one time interventions. Features such as goal tracking, daily check ins, reminders, and progress monitoring reinforce positive habits.

Support that integrates meditation, exercise, sleep improvement, reading, and device downtime encourages holistic wellbeing. These micro behaviors build momentum over time.

Consistent engagement drives long term outcomes. It transforms mental health support from a reactive service into a daily practice.

Certified Peer Support

Certified peers bring lived experience and professional training together. Their relatability fosters trust and reduces isolation. Employees often feel more comfortable opening up to someone who understands their experience firsthand.

Peer support has been shown to increase accountability, motivation, and sustained participation. In digital environments, access to certified peers creates human connection within a scalable model.

High engagement rates with certified peers and care professionals demonstrate the power of combining empathy with structure. When employees feel understood, they stay involved.

Community and Online Support Meetings

Isolation is a common feature of both mental health challenges and substance use struggles. Online support meetings and digital communities foster belonging.

Shared experiences reduce shame. Seeing others progress builds hope. Community accountability strengthens commitment to personal goals.

Digital community support also increases accessibility across locations and time zones, ensuring that help is available when it is needed most.

Family Access for Holistic Support

Providing access to family members strengthens overall outcomes. When spouses, partners, or adult dependents can engage in support services, household stress decreases.

Family inclusion reinforces positive habits and creates shared accountability. It also signals that employers recognize mental health as a whole life issue rather than a workplace issue alone.

Supporting families enhances employee stability, focus, and resilience.

From Availability to Accountability

Many employers measure success based on enrollment numbers or vendor contracts. These metrics do not reflect actual engagement or outcomes.

A more meaningful approach includes:

• Active participation rates
• Frequency of logins and goal completion
• Engagement with certified peers
• Improvements in productivity indicators
• Employee satisfaction and retention

When engagement increases, measurable outcomes follow. Organizations that prioritize consistent use rather than passive access see stronger returns on investment.

The Business Case for High Engagement Mental Health Support

Employee mental health directly affects business performance. Untreated anxiety, depression, and substance use challenges contribute to:

• Increased absenteeism
• Reduced focus and presenteeism
• Higher turnover
• Workplace safety risks
• Lower team morale

High engagement digital mental health solutions address these challenges proactively. When employees consistently interact with support tools and certified peers, they build healthier coping strategies and stronger habits.

Documented outcomes show a 67 percent increase in employee productivity alongside strong engagement with certified peers and care professionals. An 85 percent Net Promoter Score reflects high satisfaction and trust among members.

When family members also receive access to support, the positive effects extend beyond the individual employee. Reduced household stress translates into improved workplace performance.

For employers, the return is not only financial. It includes stronger culture, greater psychological safety, and improved retention in competitive labor markets.

A Blueprint for Employers Seeking Higher Engagement

Employers looking to improve utilization of workplace mental health benefits can follow a clear framework:

1. Audit current engagement levels, not just enrollment.
2. Identify confidentiality gaps and stigma barriers.
3. Prioritize digital mental health solutions that provide continuous interaction.
4. Integrate certified peer support alongside professional care.
5. Offer family access to strengthen overall impact.
6. Measure productivity, engagement, and satisfaction outcomes consistently.

This approach shifts the focus from providing benefits to ensuring those benefits are actively used and effective.

Conclusion

The problem facing employers is not a lack of mental health benefits. It is a lack of meaningful engagement.

Employees need support that is confidential, accessible, and personalized. They need ongoing accountability rather than episodic care. They need connection with certified peers who understand their experiences. And they benefit when their families are included in the solution.

Digital mental health solutions that combine technology, peer support, and strengths based goal setting create sustainable change. Engagement is the key driver of both individual wellbeing and organizational performance.

How WEconnect Works Supports Employees and Their Families

WEconnect Works is a comprehensive digital solution designed to address mental health and substance use challenges in the workplace.

The platform provides:

• Anonymous and confidential access
• Certified peer support
• Online support meetings
• Goal based habit development
• Resources for sleep, meditation, exercise, reading, and device downtime
• Access for employees and their family members

By prioritizing engagement, accountability, and holistic support, organizations can move beyond offering mental health resources and begin driving real outcomes.

To learn how WEconnect Works can strengthen employee wellbeing, reduce stigma, and improve workplace performance, connect with our team to explore a customized solution for your workforce.